Ancient Errors

Ancient coins, even though they were struck by hand - for that matter, perhaps because they were - experienced minting errors as do modern coins. Several types of errors are illustrated below.

Off-Center

Off-center coins are very common. Coins were often struck slightly to significantly shifted from the center of the planchet, though, as seen on this Diadumenian provincial, only one face is off-center.
 
 
 

Double Strike

Coins can be struck more than once. The Æ3 of Constantine (left) was struck fairly well centered on the planchet, in contrast with the Constantinopolis commemorative (right) which is almost completely off the planchet.
 
 
 

Other Doubling

Rather than a dramatic multiple strike, doubling can also be seen on only certain features of the coin, such as just the front of the portrait on this Constantine follis.
 
 
 

Flipover Double Strike

An interesting error is a flipover double strike. A coin is struck, flips over, and is struck again. The result is an impression of the reverse die on the obverse (or vice versa). This coin of Maximinus has its GENIO POPULARI ROMANI reverse struck on its obverse.
 
 
 

Ghosting

On some ancients, the design is such that one side has high relief while the other side has a flat field. The strike pushes metal into the relief, but if there is not enough enough pressure to push the metal into all aspects of the design, the metal is forced deeper into the high relief and away from the field, causing a depression on one side of the coin that corresponds to the relief on the other. This denarius of Elagabalus shows such ghosting, and the "ghost" shows the position of the relief relative to the fields.
 
 
 

Die Clash

This denarius of Julia Domna shows a die clash. If the dies come together without a planchet in between impressions of each die can be left on the other. In this case the incuse (on the die) portrait on the obverse die caused a raised feature on the reverse die. When coins were struck with these dies, the raised feature on the reverse die caused an incuse impression on the coin reverse. The letters AVG can also be seen reverse and incuse on the lower left of the reverse, in addition to the portrait. Although the image implies that the effect is the same as ghosting, ghosting occurs immediately opposite the raised feature while the clash is at any orientation (the die orientation at the time of striking).
 
 
 

Brockage

An obverse brockage occurs when a planchet that has just been struck becomes stuck in the reverse die. The next planchet struck, instead of receiving an impression of the reverse die, is impressed by the obverse of the previously struck coin. The reverse of the second coin then looks like a mirror of its obverse. This antoninianus of Gallienus is such a coin.
 
 
 

Die Cracks

This antoninianus of Licninus shows a die crack across the letter R.
 
 
 

Blundered Dies

Errors could occur that were not strike related. This antoninianus of Probus has an incorrect legend - the coin should read PROBI, not PORBI.

Please direct comments to calkinsc@lotn.org